Give us a call
920.645.2863

Meet Our Team

Advantage Insurance Agency, Inc. - Plymouth

  • Nicole Shuman

    Licensed Agent
    Office: 920-645-2863
    Fax: 920-893-5304
    N5908 Willow Road
    Plymouth WI 53073
    Get Directions >>

    Nicole graduated with honors from Lakeland College with a BS/BA in Business Administration and Marketing. Upon graduation she worked at HSA Bank as specialist with Health Savings Accounts. She then started working for Enservio in various positions including account management, team lead for claims, and operations for 8+ years. Enservio works with insurance companies around the country assisting in contents claims. In 2014 she obtained her license for Property & Casualty. By working in claims she has seen what can happen to your most important possessions during a loss. She has created a full inventory for homes that have been destroyed by fire and have worked with victims of tornados who do not have any possessions left. She enjoys working with people and believes that insurance is something that people do not think about until they have to use it which is usually a very stressful time. My job is to help you find insurance that fits your needs and if a loss would occur to make an easier process with having the right insurance in place.

  • Eloisa Rawson

    Licensed Agent
    Office: 920-645-2863
    Fax: 920-893-5304
    N5908 Willow Road
    Plymouth WI 53073
    Get Directions >>

    Eloisa graduated from UW-Milwaukee with a BS/BA on Business Management/ Global Studies and has 6 years of experience in the industry; Eloisa started working as a financial representative for Northwestern Mutual where she obtained her licensures for life and disability. After that, she worked for State farm in where she helped a new agent developed a new agency and helped become the no. 1 agency in the state of Wisconsin in 2009-2010; P&C licenses were obtained. After 2 years at State Farm she decided to start working as an independent insurance agent at a car dealership along with her brother by combining both businesses the car sales process and the selling of the insurance. She and her brother were able to create a very strong customer loyalty by committing to the client of good service and understanding to their individual needs. In these 3 years she has created a strong book of business of about 2000 active clients in where her business has been based on referrals and loyal returning clients.

Advantage Insurance Agency, Inc.- Milwaukee